GUNMAPUSA Search

Del Toro v. Polis

District Court, D. Colorado · No. 1:25-cv-02725

👎Unfavorable to gun rights

Preliminary ruling: the judge refused to block Colorado's training-and-permit requirement for buying most semiautomatic rifles, and said the plaintiffs had not shown those firearms are protected "arms" at all.

GunMapUSA assessment of the outcome's direction, not a statement that the court decided rightly or wrongly.

Where the case stands

Colorado's SB25-003 makes it unlawful to manufacture, sell, transfer or buy a "specified semiautomatic firearm" unless the buyer has gone through a permit-to-purchase process. The category covers semiautomatic rifles and shotguns with detachable magazines and gas-operated semiautomatic handguns with detachable magazines. Rimfire guns of .22 caliber or less, manually operated actions, certain recoil-operated handguns and a list of named models are excluded. A buyer must first get a course eligibility card from the county sheriff, then complete in-person training from a sheriff-verified instructor: a hunter education course plus a four-hour basic course, or a 12-hour extended course held over two days. The basic course ends with an exam that requires a score of 90 percent, and completions are reported to a statewide record system run by Colorado Parks and Wildlife. The law was signed on April 10, 2025, and the purchase requirements took effect on August 1, 2026. Five Colorado gun owners and the Colorado State Shooting Association, the state's NRA affiliate, sued Governor Jared Polis and other officials and asked for a preliminary injunction against the permit scheme. On November 4, 2026, Senior Judge William J. Martínez denied it in a 35-page order. He held that the plaintiffs had not shown at the first step of the Bruen test that the covered firearms are "arms" in common use for self-defense. The Tenth Circuit puts that question at step one, with the burden on the challenger, and the judge said he was not bound by the Third Circuit's contrary ruling in the New Jersey case. He noted that the circuits are split and that the Supreme Court is likely to resolve the question this term. He held in the alternative that the scheme is a presumptively constitutional shall-issue licensing regime under Bruen's footnote 9 and Tenth Circuit precedent, and that the plaintiffs had not shown it was put to abusive ends through delay, cost or sheriff discretion. He did not reach historical analogues. The order is preliminary and decided on a limited record. The judge reserved the shooting association's standing for a separate order. A denial of a preliminary injunction can be appealed to the Tenth Circuit immediately. The Supreme Court will hear argument on December 2, 2026 in Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins on whether AR-15-platform rifles are protected, which bears directly on the first ground of this ruling.

Summarized from the complaint and docket.

What this case is about

Second Amendment challenge to Colorado SB25-003's permit-to-purchase requirement for most semiautomatic rifles and shotguns with detachable magazines and for gas-operated semiautomatic handguns

GunMapUSA summary of the issue, not a quotation from the court.

Key Dates

  • 2025-04-10 — SB25-003 signed; the permit-to-purchase sections are delayed
  • 2026-08-01 — Permit-to-purchase sections (C.R.S. §§ 18-12-116 and 33-9-115) take effect
  • 2026-11-04 — Motion for preliminary injunction denied

Sources

Summary of public court records. Not legal advice.